Characterizing divergence through three adjacent Australian avian transition zones

Aim: The diversification of the Australian avifauna has been greatly influenced by prominent historical and modern barriers to dispersal. The aims of this study were to characterize the patterns of divergence in population pairs of meliphagoid birds across adjacent transition zones and characterize how well morphometric divergence, habitat association and taxonomic or species ranking can predict genetic divergence. Location: Northern Queensland, Australia. Methods: Genetic divergence between parental populations on either side of the three biogeographical barriers corresponding to three clusters of hybrid zones was characterized in 27 species complexes of meliphagoid birds using one mitochondrial, 23 autosomal and 12 Z chromosome loci collected from a sequence capture system. Within each species, we characterized morphometric divergence using wing, bill and tail measurements from museum samples. Lastly, we evaluated the predictive power of these morphometric measurements on genetic divergence. Results: Population pairs on either side of a transition zone depict a wide range of genomic and morphometric divergence. For some systems, species exhibiting morphometric divergence show little to no genomic divergence, while, conversely, other species exhibiting little to no morphometric divergence may show clear genomic divergence. Species rank is shown to be the strongest predictor for genetic divergence, habitat is the next strongest predictor and morphometric divergence is the weakest predictor. Main conclusions: The variation in divergence levels of population pairs affirms that transition zones are ideal natural experiments to study the speciation process. In particular, transition zones allow understanding of how genomic divergence accumulates during speciation. Additionally, standing species rank classifications mostly prove to be robust after genetic characterization. Lastly, the discordance between morphometric and genetic divergence suggests other non-morphometric phenotypic traits used to designate species rank, such as song or plumage, may play a more important role in predicting genetic divergence.