Minkish dispositions

Alan Hájek*

*Corresponding author for this work

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

    4 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Start with an ordinary disposition ascription, like ‘the wire is live’ or ‘the glass is fragile’. Lewis (Philos Quart 47:143–158, 1997) gives a canonical template for what he regards as the analysandum of such an ascription: “Something x is disposed at time t to give response r to stimulus s”. For example, (*) the wire is disposed at noon to conduct electrical current when touched by a conductor. What Lewis calls “the simple conditional analysis” gives putatively necessary and sufficient conditions for the analysandum in terms of a counterfactual: “if x were to undergo stimulus s at time t, x would give response r”. Call this the counterfactual analysans. For example: (Would-conduct) If the wire were to be touched by a conductor at noon, the wire would conduct electricity. So we have three things in play: (1) the ordinary disposition ascription (e.g. ‘the wire is live’); (2) the canonical template (e.g. *) that is supposed to formalize this disposition ascription; and (3) the counterfactual analysans that is supposed to provided an analysis of the canonical template (e.g. Would-conduct). Finkish dispositions have been widely regarded as counterexamples to the adequacy of (3) as an analysis of (2). I will argue that they are not. They succeed, however, as counterexamples to the adequacy of (3) as an analysis of (1). That said, the classic cases are somewhat contrived. I will introduce the notion of a minkish disposition: a disposition that something has, even though it might not display it in response to the relevant stimulus. Cases of minkish dispositions are entirely familiar. They refute the adequacy of (3) both as an analysis of (2) and of (1). I will argue that they also refute Lewis’s own, more complicated counterfactual analysis of dispositions, and bring out an internal tension in his views.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)4795-4811
    Number of pages17
    JournalSynthese
    Volume197
    Issue number11
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2020

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Minkish dispositions'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this