Replies to My Critics

This chapter presents Frank Jackson's response to his critics in the preceding chapters. His responses are guided by the following principles. i) There didn't seem much value in repeating points that he largely agreed with, unless he felt it could make a useful emendation or clarification; in one case, he says very little because he agreed with just about everything in the chapter and couldn't think of a better way to say what the author said. ii) As was to be expected, the same issues recur, although this happens less than might have been expected, thanks to the work of the editor.