The characteristics of regeneration failure and their potential to shift wet temperate forests into alternate stable states

Under the current trajectory of accelerated climatic and environmental change, many forests are at risk of regeneration failure and subsequent transition to alternate stable states including non-forests or grassland. These regimes shifts can have severe ecological impacts and compromise carbon stores, undermine climate change mitigation, and create conditions incompatible with the survival of biodiversity. However, detailed empirical-based understanding of the alternative states associated with disturbance regime shifts is limited. Here, using a manipulative experiment, and controlling for seed application, we document temporal patterns of vegetation structure and composition associated with regeneration failure after clearcut logging in the ash-type eucalypt forests in south-eastern Australia. Our findings clearly demonstrate that in the absence of direct seed input, frequent stand-replacing disturbance can result in regeneration failure in these forests leading to them being replaced by low species diversity Acacia woodland. These insights can be extrapolated to scenarios of post-fire regeneration failure, where frequent fire precludes the development of adequate seed-stores (<21 years). Such shifts to alternative stable states can have severe ecological implications which require management intervention to circumvent and conserve the functional integrity of these forests. Our case study demonstrates the value of manipulative empirical experiments in quantifying the potential aftermath of forest regeneration failure. Such experiments may be useful to support theories and models in quantifying the ecological implications of regeneration failure, and to guide the application of management interventions for restoration where empirical-based knowledge of these states is limited.