TY - JOUR
T1 - The idea of a 'spoon'
T2 - Semantics, prehistory, and cultural logic
AU - Wierzbicka, Anna
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2014.
PY - 2015/1/1
Y1 - 2015/1/1
N2 - The invention of the spoon may not be quite as ground-breaking in human history as the invention of the wheel or the needle, but arguably it is also a significant conceptual (as well as technological) event. It has been claimed that "all people in the world use spoons", that "spoons have been used as eating utensils since Paleolithic times", that chimpanzees in Gombe use "sort-of-spoons".. Can we draw a line, in a principled and precise way, between 'spoons' and 'sort-of' spoons'? For example, is the so-called "Chinese spoon" (tāngchí) a 'spoon'? Can we explain why a 'tāngchí' is different in many respects from a ('European') 'spoon' and similar in others? Most importantly, perhaps, can we reconstruct with any plausibility the conceptual model in the minds of the first prehistoric inventors of 'spoons'? Can we tell in what part of the world they lived, when they lived, what they wanted to eat with those first 'spoons', and why they found 'spoons' more suited to their needs than something like 'tāngchí' ('Chinese spoons')? These are some of the questions that this paper will address, using as a tool NSM techniques of semantic and conceptual analysis.
AB - The invention of the spoon may not be quite as ground-breaking in human history as the invention of the wheel or the needle, but arguably it is also a significant conceptual (as well as technological) event. It has been claimed that "all people in the world use spoons", that "spoons have been used as eating utensils since Paleolithic times", that chimpanzees in Gombe use "sort-of-spoons".. Can we draw a line, in a principled and precise way, between 'spoons' and 'sort-of' spoons'? For example, is the so-called "Chinese spoon" (tāngchí) a 'spoon'? Can we explain why a 'tāngchí' is different in many respects from a ('European') 'spoon' and similar in others? Most importantly, perhaps, can we reconstruct with any plausibility the conceptual model in the minds of the first prehistoric inventors of 'spoons'? Can we tell in what part of the world they lived, when they lived, what they wanted to eat with those first 'spoons', and why they found 'spoons' more suited to their needs than something like 'tāngchí' ('Chinese spoons')? These are some of the questions that this paper will address, using as a tool NSM techniques of semantic and conceptual analysis.
KW - Cultural logic of artefact concepts
KW - Lexicography and conceptual analysis
KW - NSM
KW - Relevance of semantics to history of food
KW - Relevance of semantics to prehistory
KW - Semantics as a key to cultural history
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84908377439&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.langsci.2014.08.005
DO - 10.1016/j.langsci.2014.08.005
M3 - Article
SN - 0388-0001
VL - 47
SP - 66
EP - 83
JO - Language Sciences
JF - Language Sciences
IS - PA
ER -